| Rank/Character/Film | Actress |
|---|
| 1. Kitty March (Scarlet Street) | |
| 2. Francie Stevens (To Catch a Thief) | |
| 3. Suzie Wong (The World of Suzie Wong) | |
| 4. Thymian (Diary of a Lost Girl) | |
| 5. Stella (Fallen Angel) | |
| 6. Mary Kate Thornton (The Quiet Man) | |
| 7. Jerry Stokes (Man Hunt) | |
| 8. Ariane Chavasse (Love in the Afternoon) | |
| 9. Gilda Mundson (Gilda) | |
| 10. Margot Shelby (Decoy) | |
| 11. Ann Smith (Mr. and Mrs. Smith) | |
| 12. Mrs. Iselin (The Manchurian Candidate) | |
| 13. Laurie Jorgensen (The Searchers) | |
| 14. Lisa Carol Fremont (Rear Window) | |
| 15. Gillian Holroyd (Bell, Book and Candle) | |
| 16. Penelope Worth (Angel and the Badman) | |
| 17. Kathleen Yorke (Rio Grande) | |
| 18. Jill McBain (Once Upon a Time in the West) | |
| 19. Pamela (The 39 Steps) | |
| 20. Scarlett O'Hara (Gone with the Wind) | |
| 21. Alicia Huberman (Notorious) | |
| 22. Maxine Faulk (The Night of the Iguana) | |
| 23. Myra Lester (Waterloo Bridge) | |
| 24. Keechie Mobley (They Live by Night) | |
| 25. Dr. Constance Petersen (Spellbound) | |
