Sports Quiz / Most Overrated/Underrated Baseball Players

Random Sports or Football Quiz

Can you name the Most Overrated and Underrated MLB Players of All-time (as of Spring 2007) as named by Jayson Stark?

 Plays Quiz not verified by Sporcle

How to Play
Score 0/24 Timer 10:00
PositionPlayerTeams Played for
Overrated CatcherPadres, Marlins, Reds, Phillies, Blue Jays, Cubs, Giants, Royals, Pirates
Underrated CatcherYankees, Mets
Overrated First BasemanDodgers, Padres
Underrated First BasemanTigers
Overrated Second BasemanDodgers, Yankees, White Sox, A's
Underrated Second BasemanAstros
Overrated Third BasemanTwins, Indians, Yankees, Padres, Braves, Expos
Underrated Third BasemanCubs, White Sox
Overrated ShortstopYankees
Underrated ShortstopReds
Overrated Left FielderCubs, Cardinals
Underrated Left FielderReds, Orioles, Dodgers, Angels, Indians
PositionPlayerTeams Played for
Overrated Center FielderBraves, Dodgers, Rangers, White Sox, Yankees
Underrated Center FielderDodgers, Mets, Giants
Overrated Right FielderPadres, Yankees, Angels, Blue Jays, Twins, Indians
Underrated Right FielderCardinals
Overrated Right-handed Starting PitcherMets, Angels, Astros, Rangers
Underrated Right-handed Starting PitcherIndians
Overrated Left-Handed Starting PitcherBrooklyn & LA Dodgers
Underrated Left-Handed Starting PitcherRed Sox, Yankees, Braves
Overrated Relief PitcherCubs, Red Sox, Cardinals, Yankees, Orioles, Angels, Reds, Expos
Underrated Relief PitcherWhite Sox, Pirates, Yankees, Padres, Cubs, Giants
Overrated Designated HitterYankees, White Sox
Underrated Designated HitterMariners

You're not logged in!

Compare scores with friends on all Sporcle quizzes.
Log In

Sporcle TV

Today on Sporcle TV

Watch our educational content, quiz creation guides, and fun videos on Sporcle TV.

Show Comments


Top Quizzes Today

Score Distribution

Your Account Isn't Verified!

In order to create a playlist on Sporcle, you need to verify the email address you used during registration. Go to your Sporcle Settings to finish the process.

Report this User

Report this user for behavior that violates our Community Guidelines.