| Year & Team(s) | Player |
|---|
| 2001- 2008, 2010: Mariners (9^) | |
| 1927, 1930- 1932, 1934, 1936- 1937 Yankees (7*) | |
| 1907, 1909, 1911- 1912, 1915- 1917 Tigers (7^) | |
| 2014- 2017: Astros (4^) | |
| 1998, 2002: Expos (2*), 2004, 2006: Angels (2*) | |
| 1984, 1986- 1987, 1989: Padres (4^) | |
| 1964, 1967, 1970- 1971: Cardinals (4^) | |
| 1948- 1949, 1951, 1953: Cardinals (4*) | |
| 1929- 1932: Phillies (4*) | |
| | Year & Team(s) | Player |
|---|
| 1998, 2006, 2009: Yankees (3^) | |
| 2001: Rockies (1^), 2003: Marlins (1^), 2006: Cubs (1^) | |
| 1996, 1998: Mariners (2*), 2001 Rangers (1*) | |
| 1977- 1979: Red Sox (3*) | |
| 1973- 1974, 1976: Twins (3^) | |
| 1964- 1965, 1970: Cubs (3*) | |
| 1929- 1930, 1932: Athletics (3*) | |
| 1922, 1925: Cardinals (2*), 1929: Cubs (1*) | |
| 1921, 1923- 1924: Yankees (3*) | |
|
