| Years & Team | Player |
|---|
| 1920- 1921, 1923- 1924, 1926- 1932: Yankees (11) | |
| 1927- 1934, 1936- 1937: Yankees (10) | |
| 1936- 1941, 1948, 1950: Yankees (8) | |
| 1939, 1941- 1942, 1946, 1948- 1949, 1961: Red Sox (7) | |
| 1934- 1935, 1937- 1938, 1940, 1946: Tigers (6) | |
| 2001- 2004, 2006, 2009: Cardinals (6) | |
| 1930- 1934: Athletics (5) | |
| 1925, 1929- 1932: Athletics (5) | |
| 1929- 1933: Phillies (5) | |
| 1925- 1929: Cardinals (4) | |
| 1996- 1997, 1999- 2001: Astros (5) | |
| 1957, 1960, 1962- 1963, 1966: Braves (5) | |
| 1927- 1928, 1929- 1930: Cubs (4) | |
| 1998- 2001: Cubs (4) | |
| 2006- 2009: Phillies (4) | |
| 1996- 1999: Mariners (4) | |
| 1996- 1999: Rangers (4) | |
| 2004- 2006, 2016: Red Sox (4) | |
| 1929, 1932, 1934, 1936: Giants (4) | |
| 1935- 1938: Cardinals (4) | |
| 2005- 2007, 2010: Yankees (4) | |
| 1993, 1996- 1997, 2000: White Sox (4) | |
| 2008, 2010, 2012- 2013: Tigers (4) | |
| 1978- 1979, 1983- 1984: Red Sox (4) | |
| 1921, 1925, 1927, 1929: Tigers (4) | |
| | Years & Team | Player |
|---|
| 1993, 1996, 1998, 2001: Giants (4) | |
| 1936- 1938: Red Sox (3) | |
| 1948- 1950: Red Sox (3) | |
| 1998- 2000: Indians (3) | |
| 1934, 1936- 1937: Indians (3) | |
| 1921- 1922, 1925: Cardinals (3) | |
| 1999- 2000, 2003: Blue Jays (3) | |
| 1993, 1995- 1996: Indians (3) | |
| 1970, 1972, 1974: Reds (3) | |
| 2001, 2004- 2005: Red Sox (3) | |
| 1995- 1996, 1999: Rockies (3) | |
| 1931- 1932, 1936: Indians (3) | |
| 1921, 1924- 1925: Yankees (3) | |
| 1953- 1955: Dodgers (3) | |
| 1999- 2001: Rangers (3) | |
| 1955, 1961- 1962: Giants (3) | |
| 2001- 2002, 2006: Astros (3) | |
| 1990- 1992: Tigers (3) | |
| 1961- 1962, 1969: Twins (3) | |
| 1959, 1961- 1962: Reds (3) | |
| 1999- 2001: Athletics (3) | |
| 1948- 1949, 1954: Cardinals (3) | |
| 1996, 1998, 2000: Mariners (3) | |
| 1947- 1949: Pirates (3) | |
| 1980, 1982- 1983: Brewers (3) | |
|
