| Hint | Answer |
|---|
| Has lived with Marshall, Lily, and Ted | |
| The intervention performed for this character was for a creepy British accent | |
| Is a Canadian and an American citizen | |
| For many years he/she dressed as a hanging chad for Halloween | |
| Had a 'perfect week' | |
| Broke the 'Bro Code' by sleeping with Robin | |
| The intervention performed for this character was for using too many fire magic tricks | |
| Marries a woman who paints pictures of robots playing sports | |
| Had a short-lived relationship with a body pillow | |
| Once dated someone nicknamed 'Scooter' | |
| A 'play' to get out of a relationship has been named after him | |
| 'Good Feeling' by the Violent Femmes is their song | |
| Routinely lies and runs plays on women to get them into bed | |
| May have, or may not have, (but probably did) win the 'Championship Belt' | |
| Shaved part of his/her own head | |
| Can be distracted by bringing up the topic of Emperor Penguins | |
| Had the nickname, 'Swarley' | |
| Is a Canadian and an American citizen | |
| Lived with Barney for a short period of time | |
| Has lived with Marshall, Lily, and Ted | |
| Has a tendency to cry during wedding toasts | |
| A 'play' to get out of a relationship has been named after him | |
| Has a bad habit of singing everything that he does | |
| Has a 'knowledge gap' regarding the pronunciation of several words, including chameleon | |
| Thought the North Pole was a fictitious place, like Hogwarts or Narnia | |
| Stabbed Lily with a sword | |
| Once dated someone nicknamed 'Scooter' | |
| Both of these characters have kissed Lily | |
| These three characters have kissed Robin | |
| Dated his/her own psychiatrist | |
| For many years he/she dressed as a hanging chad for Halloween | |
| Broke the 'Bro Code' by sleeping with Robin | |
| Dresses only in suits, except very rare and specific occassions | |
| Had a short-lived relationship with a body pillow | |
| Shaved part of his/her own head | |
| Was left at the alter | |
| Was a teenage Canadian pop sensation | |
| These characters have Canadian blood | |
| Punched Barney in the crotch | |
| Has repeatedly slapped Barney in the face | |
| The intervention performed for this character was for a creepy British accent | |
| The intervention performed for this character was for using too many fire magic tricks | |
| Was beat up by a (girl) goat | |
| Can be distracted by bringing up the topic of Emperor Penguins | |
| Routinely lies and runs plays on women to get them into bed | |
| Had a 'perfect week' | |
| Used to live with five dogs | |
| Was arrested for public urination | |
| May have, or may not have, (but probably did) win the 'Championship Belt' | |
| Had a relationship with a woman who hated Star Wars | |
| Routinely watches Predator on Valentine's Day | |
| Ran the New York City Marathon | |
| The intervention that was performed for this character was regarding the continued use of spray tans | |
| Once dated a guy called 'Scooby' | |
| These two have licked the Liberty Bell | |
| Once gave his/her name as 'Galactic President Superstar McAwesomeville' | |
| Creator of www.slapcountdown.com | |
| Had the nickname of 'Chewbacca' | |
| Constantly corrects people | |
| Says literally when they actually mean figuratively | |
| Uses a lot of outdated catchphrases | |
| Marries a woman with Ted as his best man | |
| Married the same woman three times | |
| Marries a woman who paints pictures of robots playing sports | |
| Ripped a 'window-crank' off of the inside of a taxi cab's door | |
| 'Good Feeling' by the Violent Femmes is their song | |
