Miscellaneous Quiz / Voluntary Manslaughter Revision - Diminished Responsibility

Random Miscellaneous Quiz

Can you name the Voluntary Manslaughter Cases?

Quiz not verified by Sporcle

Forced Order
Also try: 'U' Game
Challenge
Share
Tweet
Embed
Score 0/10 Timer 10:00
Case DetailsCase
Defendant a sexual psychopath who strangled a young woman and mutilated her body. Convicted of murder. Acquitted as CoA held that condition came within def of D.R.
D who was suffering from depression killed wife. Defence of D.R only available if 'partially insane'. Court quashed Murder conv and subbed manslaughter
Battered Wife Syndrome recognised
Definition of Ab of Mind (Act)
Substantial 'doesn't mean total'
Immediate effects of taking drugs or alcohol not an injury even if it did have an effect on the brain. So a 'transient' state of intox was not an ab of mind.
Jury has to decide whether the combination of the factors excluding the intox amounted to the substantial impairment of the D's responsibility
Hol said this was the wrong approach and was not what was decided in the above case.
Where D is unable to resist drinking, so that it is involuntary, this may amount to D.R. Does not consider whether alcoholism is a disease.
Same point considered. D had gone to V's flat. D claimed had awoken to V performing oral sex on him. D hit repeatedly with meat cleaver and killed him. Judge directed jury that if

You're not logged in!

Compare scores with friends on all Sporcle quizzes.
Sign Up with Email
OR
Log In

You Might Also Like...

Show Comments

Extras

Top Quizzes Today


Score Distribution

Your Account Isn't Verified!

In order to create a playlist on Sporcle, you need to verify the email address you used during registration. Go to your Sporcle Settings to finish the process.