| Clue | Character |
| Who was locked in the port-a-potty by...? | |
| Who frequently sleeps with...? | |
| Who holds pinkies with...? | |
| Who auditioned into the glee club with...? | |
| Who went to live with this girl later on in the first season...? | |
| Whose best girl friend is...? | |
| Who was paired with this person to practice her ballad...? | |
| Who doesn't have many speaking lines, along with...? | |
| Who has the principal with the last name...? | |
| Who was black-mailed by...? | |