| Hint | Villain | Season |
| Vampire and Count | |
| Demon from Outer Space with an appetite for crazy people | |
| Scabby Minion to a Hell God | |
| Reptilian Demon | |
| Troll and Anya's former Love Interest | |
| Robot and Girlfriend to the Creator | |
| Military Order and a sworn enemy of a certain Hell God | |
| Demon that brings song and dance to Sunnydale | |
| Three Friends and self proclaimed 'Supervillains' | |
| Vampire and Dawn's date on Halloween | |
| Bank Robbing Demon | |
| Vengeance Demon | |
| Demon and Spike's Loan-Shark | |
| Vampire and 'Demonic Dealer' | |
| Witch and Rat | |
| Sorcerer and 'Magic Dealer' | |
| Witch with a Vengeance | |
| Skin Eating Demon | |
| Priest and Sidekick to The First | |
| Vampire and Buffy's Old Classmate | |
| Vampire (brought forth from the Hellmouth) | |
| Demon Woman and Xander's Date | |