| Question | Answer |
| Who is Ted Mosby's favourite soul singer? | |
| What alias does Barney use at the matchmaker's in Season 1? | |
| How does Robin describe Bruce Springsteen? | |
| In 'The Pineapple Incident', what does Ted suggest Trudy do when she says she wants to do something stupid? | |
| At the club, what does Ted tell the Coat Check Girl he really hates? | |
| Which 1970s rock band did Barney's mom tour with as a groupie, leaving Barney with a babysitter? | |
| When Ted's little sister Heather comes to visit, she sells his couch and TV - in exchange for what? | |
| What form of martial arts does Ted's two-time girlfriend Natalie practice? | |
| When Lily and Marshall invite other couples over, what is the one entree that she leaves Marshall in charge of? | |
| Which Canadian television actor does Lily contact when trying to break up Robin and Barney in Season 5? | |
| | Question | Answer |
| What is the name of the barrell that Marshall leaves outside the apartment building to be taken? | |
| When a really loud couple moves in above Robin and Ted, what instrument does Old Ted say they're playing? | |
| What is the name of the faulty and dangerous coffee-maker in Ted/Lily/Marshall's apartment? | |
| What is the name of Stella's ex-husband that she ultimately leaves Ted for? | |
| Who is the Slap Bet Commissioner? | |
| Who does Jeff Coatsworth tell Marshall his only client will be if he works for him? | |
| What was the name of Marshall's iguana? | |
| What is Robin's dad's name? | |
| On New Year's Eve in Season 1, which musical celebrity does everyone think they've picked up in the limo? | |
| What insect does Ted drunkenly get tattooed on his lower back? | |
|