| Hint | Answer | Year |
| The opponent in 'The Drive' where Elway drove 98yds to advance to Super Bowl XXI | |
| The Packers quarterback in 'The Instant Replay Game' which boosted his team over the Bears on a controversial 4th Down Play | |
| The kicker who missed wide right in Super Bowl XXV | |
| The starting quarterback for the Bills in the AFC Wild Card Game known as 'The Comeback' which remains the largest comeback in NFL Playoff History | |
| Name of the AFC Wild Card Game where the Titans scored on a kickoff with time expiring | |
| The Titans player who got tackled to end Super Bowl XXXIV | |
| The controversial rule that helped the Patriots overcome the Raiders in the AFC Divisional Game | |
| The kicker who missed the extra-point after 'The River City Relay' which would have sent the game to overtime after the 75-yard 5-laterall play | |
| The down and distance the Eagles completed to tie the Packers in the playoffs to send the game into overtime | |