| Player 1 | Answer | Player 2 |
| SP - Mets/Angels/Astros/Rangers (1966-1993) | |
| OF - Tigers/Dodgers/Reds/Marlins/Giants (2003-2011) | |
| 3B - Royals (1973-1993) | |
| SP - Cardinals/Cubs/Browns (1930-1947) | |
| RP - Mariners/Yankees/Rangers/WhiteSox (1992-2006) | |
| RP - Orioles/Mets/Diamondbacks/Marlins/Rockies/Indians/Braves/Brewers (2001-2009) | |
| | Player 1 | Answer | Player 2 |
| SP - Athletics/Yankees (1965-1979) | |
| OF - Indians/Phillies (2007-2011) | |
| OF - Braves/Brewers (1954-1976) | |
| SP - Cardinals/Phillies/Giants/White Sox/Indians/Twins (1965-1988) | |
| OF - Royals/Athletics/Cubs (1976-1994) | |
| C - Dodgers/Yankees (2006-2011) | |
| | Player 1 | Answer | Player 2 |
| SP - Twins/Phillies/Reds/Dodgers (1998-2009) | |
| SP - Yankees/Athletics/Indians/Mets (1956-1967) | |
| SP - Indians/Phillies/Mariners/Rangers (2002-2011) | |
| SP - Braves/Cardinals/Cubs/Rockies/Nationals (2000-2011) | |
|