| Hint | Character | First Appearance |
| Doesn't believe the Black Pearl is a real ship | |
| A Greek goddess bound in mortal form | |
| Wears the wig for more than keeping his head warm | |
| Head of the East India Trading Company who hates Jack Sparrow with a vengeance | |
| Beckett's assistant and assassin | |
| Has a wooden eye; says krah-kin | |
| A blacksmith who would die for his dolly-belle | |
| Lord of the Mediterranean | |
| Stuck up for Jack and was awarded 100 years of service to Davy Jones | |
| First mate turned captain by mutiny | |
| Jack borrowed her boat without permission but promises her a better one | |
| Navy member turned pirate who loves rum and stories | |
| Lord of the Pacific Ocean | |
| Fish face captain of the Flying Dutchman who cut out his heart | |
| Davy Jones' ship destroying pet | |
| Named after the Black Pearl's former captain; returns himself to an undead state | |
| The blonde who slaps Jack Sparrow, which he may have deserved | |