| President | Justice | Appointment |
| Washington | |
| Washington | |
| Washington | |
| Washington | |
| Washington | |
| Washington | |
| Washington | |
| Washington | |
| Washington | |
| Washington | |
| Washington | |
| J. Adams | |
| J. Adams | |
| J. Adams | |
| Jefferson | |
| Jefferson | |
| Jefferson | |
| Madison | |
| Madison | |
| Monroe | |
| J. Q. Adams | |
| Jackson | |
| Jackson | |
| Jackson | |
| Jackson | |
| Jackson | |
| Van Buren | |
| Van Buren | |
| Van Buren | |
| Tyler | |
| Polk | |
| Polk | |
| Fillmore | |
| Pierce | |
| Buchanan | |
| Lincoln | |
| Lincoln | |
| Lincoln | |
| Lincoln | |
| | President | Justice | Appointment |
| Lincoln | |
| Grant | |
| Grant | |
| Grant | |
| Grant | |
| Hayes | |
| Hayes | |
| Garfield | |
| Arthur | |
| Arthur | |
| Cleveland | |
| Cleveland | |
| B. Harrison | |
| B. Harrison | |
| B. Harrison | |
| B. Harrison | |
| Cleveland | |
| Cleveland | |
| McKinley | |
| T. Roosevelt | |
| T. Roosevelt | |
| T. Roosevelt | |
| Taft | |
| Taft | |
| Taft | |
| Taft | |
| Taft | |
| Taft | |
| Wilson | |
| Wilson | |
| Wilson | |
| Harding | |
| Harding | |
| Harding | |
| Harding | |
| Coolidge | |
| Hoover | |
| Hoover | |
| Hoover | |
| | President | Justice | Appointment |
| F. Roosevelt | |
| F. Roosevelt | |
| F. Roosevelt | |
| F. Roosevelt | |
| F. Roosevelt | |
| F. Roosevelt | |
| F. Roosevelt | |
| F. Roosevelt | |
| F. Roosevelt | |
| Truman | |
| Truman | |
| Truman | |
| Truman | |
| Eisenhower | |
| Eisenhower | |
| Eisenhower | |
| Eisenhower | |
| Eisenhower | |
| Kennedy | |
| Kennedy | |
| L.B. Johnson | |
| L.B. Johnson | |
| Nixon | |
| Nixon | |
| Nixon | |
| Nixon | |
| Ford | |
| Reagan | |
| Reagan | |
| Reagan | |
| Reagan | |
| G.H.W. Bush | |
| G.H.W. Bush | |
| Clinton | |
| Clinton | |
| G.W. Bush | |
| G.W. Bush | |
| Obama | |
|