| Hint | Answer |
| Barney is played by... | |
| His regular bar is... | |
| He always wears a..., even to bed | |
| Barney has been with at least this many women | |
| Barney has an obsession with this shooting game | |
| Barney loses this painful wager to Marshall | |
| He has a giant one of these in his apartment | |
| Barney also has a life-size one of these | |
| He often describes himself as... | |
| He describes his favorite things as... | |
| | Hint | Answer |
| Barney once believed this celebrity was his father | |
| The name of Barney's real father is... | |
| He has a black, gay brother named... | |
| Barney lives by this set of laws (he may have written himself) | |
| One of Marshall's dates thought Barney's name was... | |
| He works for this company, though his job there is a mystery... | |
| In college, Barney was a... | |
| Barney's doppelganger's name is... | |
| Barney used to be in a relationship with this other main character | |
| Challenge accepted! Barney may actually settle down with this woman | |
|