| Year/Team (Position) | Player | Batting Average, Home Runs |
| 1947 CLE (OF) | |
| 1968 NYY (SS/OF) | |
| 1969 ATL (C) | |
| 1971 CAL (OF/1B) | |
| 1972 PIT (1B/OF) | |
| 1972 MIN (3B) | |
| 1973 PHI (3B) | |
| 1974 MIL (2B) | |
| 1974 OAK/MIL/BOS (DH/1B) | |
| 1975 KC (DH/1B) | |
| 1975 MIL (OF) | |
| 1976 CHC/MON (1B) | |
| 1983 SEA/BAL (3B) | |
| 1983 CAL (DH/OF) | |
| 1983 NYM (1B) | |
| 1984 CIN (3B/1B) | |
| 1984 NYY (DH/OF) | |
| 1986 SEA/MIL (DH/1B) | |
| | Year/Team (Position) | Player | Batting Average, Home Runs |
| 1987 MIN (C) | |
| 1987 SF (C) | |
| 1990 HOU (OF) | |
| 1990 NYY (DH/1B) | |
| 1991 DET (OF) | |
| 1991 PHI (C) | |
| 1991 TEX (3B) | |
| 1993 BAL (3B) | |
| 1999 MON/CHC (3B) | |
| 1999 SD (OF) | |
| 2001 CHC (C) | |
| 2001 STL (1B) | |
| 2007 SD/PHI/STL (3B/OF) | |
| 2007 TB (OF) | |
| 2010 WAS (OF) | |
| 2010 TB (1B) | |
| 2010 ARI (3B) | |
|