| Leading Man | Broadway Show |
| Don Quixote | |
| Bobby | |
| Curly | |
| Benjamin Barker | |
| Gaylord Ravenal | |
| Georg von Trapp | |
| The Baker | |
| Harold Hill | |
| Horace Vandegelder | |
| Billy Flynn | |
| Sky Masterson | |
| Prince Dauntless | |
| Tevya | |
| Billy Bigelow | |
| Seymour | |
| Adam | |
| Jesus Christ | |
| The Balladeer | |
| Princeton | |
| Erik (name from the book version) | |
| | Leading Man | Broadway Show |
| Huckleberry Finn | |
| Jamie | |
| Leo Frank | |
| Henry Higgins | |
| Emcee | |
| Arthur Pendragon | |
| Prince Charming | |
| Ed Klaban | |
| Frank Choffey | |
| Nicky Arnstein | |
| Danny Zucko | |
| Claude | |
| Link Larkin | |
| Edward Rochester | |
| Henry Jekyll | |
| John Adams | |
| Jean Valjean | |
| Fabrizzio Nacarelli | |
| Frederick Armfeldt | |
| Coalhouse Walker Jr. | |
|