| Play | Athlete | Game |
| Hit the ball that went through Bill Buckner's legs. | |
| Threw the final inbound pass to Christian Laettner. | |
| Defended Michael Jordan on the buzzer beater that beat Cleveland. | |
| Defended Michael Jordan as Jordan hit his final shot as a Bull. | |
| Threw the lateral to Kevin Dyson in the 'Music City Miracle.' | |
| Hit a walk-off home run off of Mitch Williams to win the World Series. | |
| Forced Leon Lett to fumble the ball in the end zone. | |
| Called a time-out (with none remaining) for Michigan, resulting in a technical foul. | |
| Called out at home after Derek Jeter's famous 'flip' relay to Jorge Posada. | |
| Made a game-winning layup assisted by Larry Bird after Bird stole an inbound pass from Isiah Thomas. | |
| Caught the pass from Joe Montana in what is known as 'The Catch.' | |
| Hit Tom Brady, causing Brady to drop the ball, which was controversially ruled an incomplete pass. | |