| Position(s) | Player | Years with Indians |
| 3B/SS/2B | |
| SP/RP | |
| DH/C | |
| C | |
| RP | |
| DH | |
| PH/LF/RF | |
| LF/RF/CF | |
| RP | |
| RP | |
| RP | |
| RP | |
| PH/LF | |
| RP/SP | |
| C | |
| 2B/LF/RF | |
| SP | |
| RP | |
| SP/RP | |
| SP | |
| SS | |
| RF/DH/LF | |
| C | |
| 2B | |
| SP/RP | |
| SP | |
| SP | |
| RP/SP | |
| 2B | |
| 2B | |
| SP/RP | |
| CF | |
| RP | |
| SP | |
| SP/RP | |
| LF/CF/1B/RF | |
| RF/DH | |
| LF/DH | |
| RP | |
| DH/PH/RF | |
| RP/SP | |
| RP | |
| SP | |
| PH/PR/LF | |
| SP/RP | |
| RP | |
| RF/DH | |
| DH | |
| RP/SP | |
| RP | |
| C | |
| SP | |
| C | |
| LF | |
| C | |
| SS/2B | |
| RP/SP | |
| SP/RP | |
| C | |
| SP/RP | |
| SP | |
| SS | |
| C | |
| SS/2B | |
| SS/2B | |
| | Position(s) | Player | Years with Indians |
| DH | |
| RP | |
| RF/DH | |
| CF | |
| SP/RP | |
| RP | |
| DH/3B | |
| RP | |
| DH/1B/LF | |
| SP/RP | |
| LF | |
| 1B | |
| 3B | |
| C | |
| RP | |
| RF/LF/DH | |
| SP/RP | |
| LF | |
| 1B | |
| 2B | |
| RP | |
| 3B | |
| DH/LF/CF | |
| RP | |
| 2B/SS | |
| DH | |
| RP | |
| CF/RF | |
| RP | |
| LF/3B/SS/1B | |
| DH/PH | |
| RP | |
| DH | |
| CF | |
| 2B | |
| RP | |
| C | |
| RP | |
| SS | |
| RP | |
| LF/CF | |
| C | |
| CF | |
| RF/DH | |
| LF | |
| DH/1B | |
| 2B/SS/3B | |
| RP | |
| PH/LF/RF | |
| 3B | |
| 2B/SS | |
| C | |
| SP/RP | |
| SP | |
| LF/CF | |
| 2B/SS | |
| RP | |
| 1B | |
| RP/SP | |
| RP | |
| RP | |
| RF | |
| RP/SP | |
| PH/1B | |
| PH/DH | |
| | Position(s) | Player | Years with Indians |
| RP | |
| 2B | |
| PH/1B | |
| RP | |
| PH/RF | |
| C | |
| 2B/1B/SS | |
| RP/SP | |
| LF | |
| RP | |
| SP/RP | |
| 2B/3B/SS | |
| SP/RP | |
| SP/RP | |
| 2B/3B | |
| RP/SP | |
| DH/C | |
| RP | |
| SP | |
| SP/RP | |
| RP | |
| DH/3B/LF | |
| SP/RP | |
| C | |
| SP/RP | |
| RF/SS | |
| SP | |
| RP/SP | |
| RP | |
| RP | |
| RP | |
| SP/RP | |
| SP | |
| 1B/LF/DH | |
| CF | |
| RP | |
| DH | |
| C | |
| 2B | |
| SP/RP | |
| 1B | |
| RP | |
| DH | |
| SS | |
| RP | |
| RF/LF | |
| RP | |
| SP/RP | |
| RP/SP | |
| SP/RP | |
| SS/3B/2B | |
| RP/SP | |
| RP | |
| RP | |
| C | |
| 3B/LF | |
| LF/RF | |
| RP | |
| 1B/DH | |
| RP/SP | |
| RP/SP | |
| DH/LF | |
| SS | |
|