| Hint | Person |
| Second man on the moon | |
| Second highest NBA scorer | |
| Second president of the United States | |
| Second assassinated president of the United States | |
| Second team to win a Superbowl | |
| Second highest MLB home run total | |
| Second most NHL goals | |
| Second Daytona 500 winner | |
| Second highest grossing film | |
| Second best American college according to Forbes Magazine | |
| Second richest person in the world according to Forbes Magazine | |
| Second person to climb Mt. Everest | |
| Second tallest male in recorded history | |
| Second WWF World Champion | |
| Second highest mountain in the world | |
| Second most expensive Monopoly property | |
| Second book in the Lord of the Rings trilogy | |
| Second state to join the Union | |
| Second planet from the sun | |
| Second most Olympic medals all time (country) | |
| Second coach of the Dallas Cowboys | |
| Second tallest skyscraper in the world | |