| Which of These Two Characters Die? | Answer | Time & Place of Death |
| Peter Pettigrew or Gregory Goyle | |
| Andromeda Tonks or Aragog | |
| Gregorovitch or Mundngus Fletcher | |
| Griphook or Gornuk | |
| Severus Snape or Xenophilius Lovegood | |
| Antonin Dolohov or Fred Weasley | |
| Bellatrix Lestrange or Stan Shunpike | |
| Dean Thomas or Dobby | |
| Vincent Crabbe or Augustus Rookwood | |
| Neville Longbottom or Lily Potter | |
| Gilderoy Lockhart or Remus Lupin | |
| James Potter or Hagrid | |
| Rufus Scrimgeour or Cornelius Fudge | |
| Draco Malfoy or Frank Bryce | |
| Broderick Bode or Narcissa Malfoy | |
| Albus Dumbledore or Aberforth Dumbledore | |
| Kreacher or Hokey | |
| Quirinus Quirrell or Luna Lovegood | |
| Pigwidgeon or Hedwig | |
| Arthur Weasley or Merope Gaunt | |
| Peter Pettigrew or Gregory Goyle | |
| Andromeda Tonks or Aragog | |
| Gregorovitch or Mundngus Fletcher | |
| Griphook or Gornuk | |
| Severus Snape or Xenophilius Lovegood | |
| Antonin Dolohov or Fred Weasley | |
| Bellatrix Lestrange or Stan Shunpike | |
| Dean Thomas or Dobby | |
| Vincent Crabbe or Augustus Rookwood | |
| Neville Longbottom or Lily Potter | |