| Year | Player | Team |
| Central Michigan | |
| Northern Illinois | |
| Bowling Green | |
| Bowling Green | |
| Miami | |
| Kent State | |
| Western Michigan | |
| Ball State | |
| Central Michigan | |
| Bowling Green | |
| Bowling Green | |
| Ball State | |
| Central Michigan | |
| Toledo | |
| Ball State | |
| | Year | Player | Team |
| Marshall | |
| Miami | |
| Marshall | |
| Western Michigan | |
| Marshall | |
| Marshall | |
| Miami | |
| Akron | |
| Toledo/Western Michigan | |
| Northern Illinois | |
| Northern Illinois | |
| Northern Illinois | |
| Central Michigan | |
| Northern Illinois | |
| Northern Illinois | |
|