| Hint | Person | Sport |
| Hit 755 career home runs for the Braves | |
| Shortstop for White Sox and Orioles, first Venezualan elected to the Hall of Fame | |
| World Series-winning manager for the Reds and Tigers | |
| Hall of Fame shortstop for the White Sox, nicknamed 'Old Aches And Pains' | |
| Quarterbacked the Cowboys to three Super Bowls | |
| Former MVP for the Seahawks | |
| Hall of Fame running back for USC and the Raiders | |
| Dutch-born kicker who set records in games played and points scored | |
| Nuggets forward who won an NCAA championship with Syracuse | |
| Former sharpshooting guard, now the general manager of the Celtics | |
| NBA's career points leader (and he's not the co-pilot) | |
| | Hint | Person | Sport |
| Coach who won nine titles with the Celtics | |
| Coached exactly 1,500 games for the Islanders | |
| Well-traveled left winger, ex-boyfriend of Elisha Cuthbert | |
| Won the 1992 Daytona 500 | |
| Eldest of the most prolific racing Indy racing family | |
| Won eight career Grand Slam championships | |
| Won the 1993 PGA Championship, captained the 2008 USA Ryder Cup team | |
| The greatest | |
| Seven-time Tour de France winner | |
| Won Triple Crowns with Whirlaway and Citation | |
|