| Hint | Character |
| Father | |
| Aunt | |
| Aunt | |
| Aunt who lives at the Pleasure Dome | |
| First boyfriend | |
| Cat | |
| First best friend | |
| Second best friend | |
| Ex-fiance | |
| Popular cheerleader | |
| Cheerleader's sidekick | |
| Cheerleader's other sidekick | |
| Head of the Witches' Council | |
| Head of the Witches' Council's 'Underling' | |
| Witch whom Sabrina tutors | |
| | Hint | Character |
| Quizmaster | |
| Sabrina's evil twin | |
| Vice Principal of Westbridge High | |
| Westbridge High science teacher | |
| Nervous Westbridge High teacher | |
| Male college roommate | |
| Sarcastic female college roommate | |
| Popular female college roommate | |
| Co-worker at the coffee house | |
| Witch hunter | |
| Troublemaker cousin | |
| Younger cousin | |
| The above cousins' mother | |
| Troll | |
|