| Clue | Player/Team |
| 2009-This player intercepted Kurt Warner and returned it for a 100 yard TD | |
| 1966-This team won the very first Super Bowl | |
| 2002-This player hit a 48 yard field goal to stop 'The Greatest Show on Turf' | |
| 1991-This player missed a field goal that would have won the Super Bowl for the Bills | |
| 2000-Kevin Dyson was tackled by this player on the 1 yard line to end Super Bowl XXXIV | |
| 1972-This is the only team to go undefeated in the Super Bowl era | |
| 2010-This player picked off Peyton Manning and returned it for a TD to seal the Saints 1st Super Bowl win | |
| 1969-This player followed up on his promise, getting one of the biggest upsets in Super Bowl history | |
| 2008-This player made the helmet catch that led to one of the biggest upsets in Super Bowl history | |
| 1983-This player scored a 43 yard TD on 4th and 1 to give the Redskins the lead | |
| 2010-This team started the 2nd half with an onside kick and recovered it | |
| 2009-This player scored in the corner of the endzone to kill the Cardinals hopes of winning their first Super Bowl | |