| Position/Years Played for Yankees | Player | Position/Years Played for Red Sox |
| P 1903 | |
| P 1933 | |
| 2B 2005 | |
| OF/3B 1979 | |
| 3B 1993–1997 | |
| P 1962 | |
| P 1976 | |
| PH/1B 1928-1929 | |
| P 1922-1924 | |
| C 2009 | |
| P 1999-2003;2007 | |
| P 1961-1962 | |
| OF 1966-1967 | |
| P 1995-2000 | |
| C 1910 | |
| 1B/3B 1937-1940 | |
| OF 2006-2009 | |
| OF/3B 1904-1906 | |
| 3B/2B 1922-1928 | |
| P 1938-1939 | |
| P 1901-1902 | |
| IF 2007 | |
| P 1921 | |
| P 1928-1929 | |
| OF 1908-1911 | |
| 1B/OF 2009 | |
| 1B 1982 | |
| C 1955-67 | |
| | Position/Years Played for Yankees | Player | Position/Years Played for Red Sox |
| P 1921-1930 | |
| OF 1936-1937 | |
| P/OF 1922-1926 | |
| IF/OF 1909-1911, 1913 | |
| P 1951 | |
| OF 1919-1920 | |
| P 1972-1978 | |
| P 1932-1934 | |
| P 1919-1923 | |
| P 1956 | |
| P 1952-1954 | |
| P 1913-1915 | |
| P 1982 | |
| IF 1921-1925 | |
| P 1996–2002, 2005 | |
| 1B 2007 | |
| OF 1940 | |
| P 1966-1967 | |
| C 1973 | |
| P 1947 | |
| C/1B 1914-1917 | |
| 1B 2004 | |
| C 1925 | |
| OF 1924-1929 | |
| P 1923-1933 | |
| P 1902 | |
| OF 1921 | |
| P/OF 1930-1942, 1945–1946 | |
| | Position/Years Played for Yankees | Player | Position/Years Played for Red Sox |
| OF/1B/P 1920-1934 | |
| P 1952-1953 | |
| C 1921-1925 | |
| SS 1922-1925 | |
| 1B 1979 | |
| OF/IF 1925 | |
| P 1919-1920 | |
| OF 1922-1923 | |
| OF/1B 1908 | |
| P 1979-1980 | |
| C 1967 | |
| OF 1925 | |
| P 1946 | |
| P 1970-1971 | |
| P 1997-1998, 2002–2003 | |
| OF 1913 | |
| OF/1B 1910-1913 | |
| 2B 2005 | |
| P 1968 | |
| OF 1950-1952 | |
| P 2006-2007 | |
| 1B 2004 | |
| P 1997-2002, 2005 | |
| P 1996-1999 | |
| P 2005 | |
| C 1990-1996, 1999-2000 | |
| OF 1985-1989 | |
|