@bama: sorry for the delay in responding. I chose 1972 because it was a round number of years ago and because it was the first such year I personally remember. (I was alive in 1962, but I was kind of busy teething. ;)) The '62 list is pretty good - it starts with two gems, ends with two more, and there are quite a few good ones in the middle like "Sheila", "I Can't Stop Loving You" and "Monster Mash". No complaints here.
Yeah, I'll admit I posted the original list for rhetorical purposes -- like @rockgolf, I don't want to get into any generational battles with our younger Sporclers, and I know it's downright trite to believe that one's own generation produced the best music. But, yes too, I believe that a much greater percentage of the 1972 songs are still going to be played and popular in 40 years than the 13 #1s from 2012. I think the 'timelessness' of music has been on the downswing for quite a while -- not necessarily that it's getting worse, mind you, but it seems much more fleeting and throwaway. Let's look at the other 10-year anniversary lists since '72 for examples (sorry in advance for the length):
1982
----
"Abracadabra" - Steve Miller Band
"Centerfold" - J. Geils Band
"Chariots Of Fire" - Vangelis
"Don't You Want Me" - The Human League
"Ebony And Ivory" - Paul McCartney and Stevie Wonder
"Eye Of The Tiger" - Survivor
"Hard To Say I'm Sorry" - Chicago
"I Can't Go For That (No Can Do)" - Hall And Oates
"I Love Rock 'n' Roll" - Joan Jett and the Blackhearts
"Jack & Diane" - John Cougar Mellencamp
"Maneater" - Hall and Oates
"Mickey" - Toni Basil
"Physical" - Olivia Newton-John
"Truly" - Lionel Richie
"Up Where We Belong" - Joe Cocker & Jennifer Warnes
"Who Can It Be Now?" - Men At Work
On the whole, a good list, but just not as strong top to bottom as '72. Weighed down by a few hits by super artists who did MUCH better work in other years (ONJ, Paul/Stevie, Chicago and Lionel Richie come quickly to mind.) |