| Show, role | Broadway actor/actress | Movie actor/actress |
| Chicago, Roxie Hart | |
| Chicago, Velma Kelly | |
| Chicago, Billy Flynn | |
| West Side Story; Maria | |
| West Side Story; Tony | |
| West Side Story; Anita | |
| West Side Story; Bernardo | |
| West Side Story; Riff | |
| Phantom of the Opera; Phantom | |
| Phantom of the Opera, Christine | |
| Phantom of the Opera; Raul | |
| Phantom of the Opera, Carlotta | |
| Phantom of the Opera; Mdme. Giry | |
| Jesus Christ Superstar; Jesus | |
| Jesus Christ Superstar; Judas | |
| Jesus Christ Superstar; Mary | |
| Camelot; King Arthur | |
| Camelot; Guinevere | |
| | Show, role | Broadway actor/actress | Movie actor/actress |
| Camelot; Launcelot | |
| Camelot; Mordred | |
| Camelot; Pellinore | |
| Sweeney Todd; Todd/Benjamin Barker | |
| Sweeney Todd; Mrs Lovett | |
| Sweeney Todd; Judge Turpin | |
| Sweeney Todd; Anthony | |
| Sweeney Todd; Johanna | |
| Sweeney Todd; Pirelli | |
| Sweeney Todd; Tobias | |
| Sweeney Todd; Begger Woman | |
| My Fair Lady; Henry Higgins | |
| My Fair Lady; Eliza Doolittle | |
| My Fair Lady; Col. Pickering | |
| My Fair Lady; Alfred P. Doolittle | |
| My Fair Lady; Mrs Higgins | |
| My Fair Lady; Freddy Eynsford-Hill | |
|