| School | Player |
| Cincinnati (2000) | |
| Indiana (2000) | |
| Iowa State (2000) | |
| Texas (2000) | |
| Notre Dame (2000) | |
| Duke (2001) | |
| Duke (2001) | |
| North Carolina (2001) | |
| Notre Dame (2001) | |
| Stanford (2001) | |
| Duke (2002) | |
| Maryland (2002) | |
| Kansas (2002) | |
| Cincinnati (2002) | |
| Gonzaga (2002) | |
| Xavier (2003) | |
| Texas (2003) | |
| Kansas (2003) | |
| Marquette (2003) | |
| Wake Forest (2003) | |
| Connecticut (2004) | |
| St. Joseph's (2004) | |
| Mississippi State (2004) | |
| Providence (2004) | |
| Stanford (2004) | |
| Utah (2005) | |
| Wake Forest (2005) | |
| Duke (2005) | |
| | School | Player |
| Kansas (2005) | |
| Syracuse (2005) | |
| Duke (2006) | |
| Gonzaga (2006) | |
| Villanova (2006) | |
| Washington (2006) | |
| Duke (2006) | |
| Texas (2007) | |
| Wisconsin (2007) | |
| Texas A&M (2007) | |
| Ohio State (2007) | |
| UCLA (2007) | |
| North Carolina (2008) | |
| Kansas State (2008) | |
| Texas (2008) | |
| Memphis (2008) | |
| UCLA (2008) | |
| Pittsburgh (2009) | |
| Davidson (2009) | |
| Oklahoma (2009) | |
| North Carolina (2009) | |
| Arizona State (2009) | |
| Ohio State (2010) | |
| Kentucky (2010) | |
| Syracuse (2010) | |
| Villanova (2010) | |
| Kentucky (2010) | |
|