| Hint | Answer |
| Dean's Baby | |
| Sam's Girlfriend | |
| The First Seal | |
| 'Yellow Eyes's Actual Name | |
| Order the Horsemen Appear In | |
| Sam's LSat Score | |
| Finish the Quote: 'You're like the rat that pushes the pleasure button...' | |
| Name of the Pagan God in 'Fallen Idols' | |
| Name of the Third Winchester Brother | |
| What year did Samuel Colt make his gun? | |
| | Hint | Answer |
| Name of Dean's torturer in Hell | |
| Name of Lucifer's Temporary Vessel | |
| Name of Castiel's Vessel | |
| What Dean thinks MySpace is | |
| Finish the Quote: 'It's not food anymore, | |
| Year Zachariah sends Dean in Season Five | |
| Who killed herself when Meg died? | |
| The FBI agent who hunts Sam and Dean | |
| The Final Seal | |
| Name of the demon Sam goes with | |
|