| Clue | Answer |
| The person who sends them texts | |
| Aria's dad | |
| Hanna's boyfriend | |
| Guy that Aria used to have a crush on | |
| What Melissa dressed up as for the dance | |
| Hanna pushes him into a lake at the lakehouse | |
| Jason is Spencer's ______ | |
| Gets Melissa pregnant | |
| Aria's little brother commits what crime? | |
| Who gets drunk at their dad's wedding rehearsal? | |
| Who trashes Byron's office with Aria? | |
| What does Aria find in her locker? | |