| actor | villain |
| Frank Gorshin and John Astin | |
| Burgess Meredith | |
| Cesar Romero | |
| George Sanders, Eli Wallach, and Otto Preminger | |
| Anne Baxter | |
| David Wayne | |
| Malachi Throne | |
| Julie Newmar and Eartha Kitt | |
| Victor Buono | |
| Roddy McDowall | |
| Art Carney | |
| Van Johnson | |
| Shelley Winters | |
| Walter Slezak | |
| Vincent Price | |
| Liberace | |
| | actor | villain |
| Carolyn Jones | |
| Cliff Robertson | |
| Maurice Evans | |
| Michael Rennie | |
| Roger C. Carmel | |
| Tallulah Bankhead | |
| Joan Collins | |
| Ethel Merman | |
| Milton Berle | |
| Anne Baxter | |
| Rudy Vallee | |
| Glynis Johns | |
| Barbara Rush | |
| Ida Lupino | |
| Howard Duff | |
| Zsa Zsa Gabor | |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
|