| Hint | Musical |
| The Internet is for Porn | |
| I'm Not at All in Love | |
| I Want You Baby | |
| In Pursuit of Excellence | |
| Twice in Every Show | |
| The Oldest Established | |
| One Boy | |
| How I Know You | |
| Waiting for Life | |
| Not That Kind of Thing | |
| I Shall Scream | |
| Everybody Loves Louis | |
| Out of My Sight | |
| Betrayed | |
| Close Every Door | |
| | Hint | Musical |
| Someone is Waiting | |
| Your Eyes | |
| Atlantic City | |
| Rose Stopnik Can Cook | |
| Dog Eats Dog | |
| Breeze Off the River | |
| Please Don't Touch Me | |
| Not a Day Goes By | |
| Bloody Mary | |
| We Are Descended | |
| The Speed Test | |
| Maison Des Lunes | |
| It's Gonna Be Good | |
| Something Just Broke | |
| The Swamps of Home | |
|