| Clue | Name | Flagship Name |
| Famous British Explorer (Discoverer of Hawaii) | |
| Victim of a famous mutiny | |
| Youngest Captain in Starfleet | |
| Most feared pirate captain in U.S. waters | |
| First Englishman to sail around the world | |
| Superhero with a shield | |
| Welsh buccaneer (or a famous rum) | |
| Hates crocodiles, ticking, and kids | |
| Superhero with earth powers | |
| I have not yet begun to fight! | |
| | Clue | Name | Flagship Name |
| Hates white whales | |
| Accused pirate whose last name rhymes with 'lid' | |
| Father of the American Navy | |
| Italian Explorer, Spanish Employed (Discoverer of the New World) | |
| Portuguese explorer first to sail from Europe to India | |
| neabbiraC eht fo setariP | |
| Battle of Trafalgar | |
| Skipper of the Exxon Valdez | |
| He's seen the 'far side of the world' | |
| Won the Battle of Lake Erie | |
|