| Numbers | Musical | Hint |
| Politics and Poker, Gentleman Jimmy, Little Tin Box | |
| That's for Me, More than Just a Friend, Next Time it Happens | |
| Atlantic City, Goodbye My Love, Back to Before | |
| Twenty Miles from Marietta, All the Wasted Time, The Old Red Hills of Home | |
| Starting from the Bottom, Can This Be Love, That Thing I Can't Seem to Forget | |
| Brand New World, The Sound of Love, In America | |
| You Must Meet my Wife, The Miller's Son, Every Day a Little Death | |
| Artificial Flowers, The Picture of Happiness, How the Money Changes Hands | |
| | Numbers | Musical | Hint |
| If I Were a Man, Paris Makes Me Horny, Almost a Love Song | |
| Follow your Heart, Run Freedom Run, I See a River | |
| There She Is, Barrett's Song, Still | |
| Marry Me Now, Without You, Give a Man Enough Rope | |
| Open Your Heart, Unsuspecting Hearts, Out for Blood | |
| Tell Me on a Sunday, Take That Look Off Your Face, Unexpected Song | |
| Gun Song, Unworthy of Your Love, Another National Anthem | |
|