| Hint | Member |
| Nicknamed 'Aurochs' by the master-at-arms | |
| Traveled with a mummer's troupe | |
| Wildling who joined the Night's Watch | |
| Most accomplished climber in the Night's Watch | |
| Prologue point-of-view chapter in AGoT | |
| Male prostitute | |
| Singer, killed by Arya Stark | |
| Killer of #1 | |
| Becomes 'maester' after the other maester dies | |
| Skilled archer who teaches new recruits | |
| Slain by an Other in the prologue of AGoT | |
| Helped kill #1, body found by Summer beyond The Wall | |
| Named Commander of Long Barrow | |
| Left the Night's Watch, became King-Beyond-The-Wall | |
| Went with Jon to swear his vows, sent beyond The Wall and never returned | |
| Appointed First Ranger in 5th book | |