| Year/Team | Player | Number of TDs |
| 1964 Baltimore | |
| 1965 Chicago | |
| 1965 Cleveland | |
| 1968 Cleveland | |
| 1975 Buffalo | |
| 1975 Minnesota | |
| 1983 Washington | |
| 1983 Los Angeles Rams | |
| 1985 New York Giants | |
| 1987 San Francisco | |
| 1994 Dallas | |
| 1995 Dallas | |
| 1996 Washington | |
| | Year/Team | Player | Number of TDs |
| 1998 Denver | |
| 2000 St. Louis | |
| 2001 St. Louis | |
| 2002 Kansas City | |
| 2003 Kansas City | |
| 2003 Green Bay | |
| 2004 Seattle | |
| 2005 Seattle | |
| 2005 Kansas City | |
| 2005 San Diego | |
| 2006 San Diego | |
| 2007 New England | |
| 2008 Carolina | |
|