| Hint | Villain | Movie |
| toy torturer from next door | |
| villain with the big drill | |
| grasshopper leader | |
| toy miner who lived in box | |
| Shark turned good | |
| purple lizard-like monster | |
| Toy kidnapper | |
| redheaded girl who kills fish | |
| Food critic turned good | |
| | Hint | Villain | Movie |
| wannabe superhero and former Mr. Incredible fan | |
| selfish green car who wanted to win a piston cup | |
| Chef who hates rats and like microwavable meals | |
| robot who wanted everyone to stay on the Axiom | |
| Barbie boyfriend turned good | |
| old man who was looking for the bird | |
| evil teddy bear | |
| Monsters Incorporated owner turned evil | |
|