| Hint / Nickname | Player | Position |
| The Dude / Nails | |
| Dutch | |
| Baseball Tonight Analyst | |
| No Mickey Mouse Club here | |
| The Kid | |
| I dont have a hint for this guy | |
| Eisie | |
| Inky | |
| Bloody Sock? | |
| Phils current hitting coach | |
| Slam Duncan | |
| | Hint / Nickname | Player | Position |
| The career backup | |
| Shares a last name with a 100pt NBAer | |
| Current Phillies GM | |
| I want to Pump you UP! | |
| LA | |
| Tommy gun | |
| This guy pitched forever | |
| The opposite of east | |
| Same last name as Answer 17 | |
| Wild Thing | |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
|