| Hint | Team | Extra Information |
| This team lost their first ever regular season game to the Steelers, sparking a 4-decade rivalry | |
| The team won both their first playoff game and their first Super Bowl in the 2000s | |
| The trophy for the AFC Championship is named after the founder of this team | |
| This team's current general manager was a hall of fame player for one of their division rivals | |
| This team has had either the first or second pick in the NFL draft for 3 straight years | |
| This team changed their name 3 times in the 1990s | |
| The past three times this team played Atlanta, the games went to overtime | |
| This was the only team to finish the 2008 preseason a perfect 4-0 | |
| This team was the first NFL expansion team to make the playoffs in 3 of its first 4 seasons | |
| This team has the record for most NFL championships | |
| The first defensive player to win the NFL MVP did it playing for this team | |
| This team is the only NFL team to have played in both the AFC and NFC Championship Games | |
| This team is the only NFC team to win 100 games in the 2000s | |
| This team lost their first 26 regular season games, not recording their first victory until the second to last game of their second season | |
| The most recent team to miss the playoffs with an 11-5 record | |
| This team drafted the first of two Super Bowl winning quarterbacks in the 2004 draft | |