| Hint | Topping Name |
| classic | |
| classic #2 | |
| green stuff | |
| I'll give you this one... Coney Sauce | |
| Slaw named cole ;) | |
| warm, hot, thick, and red/brown | |
| get your mayo... get your mayo! | |
| American...Cottage...Swiss... | |
| they make your eyes water before cooked | |
| it's sour and krout... except spelled differently | |