| Number | Wrestler | First event |
| 71 (46, 25, 0) | |
| 63 (56, 7, 0) | |
| 56 (36, 20, 0) | |
| 48 (35, 13, 0) | |
| 39 (19, 11, 9) | |
| 37 (14, 23, 0) | |
| 34 (5, 29, 0) | |
| 32 (13, 17, 3) | |
| 31 (WWE) | |
| 30 (22, 8, 0) | |
| 29 (WWE) | |
| 27 (9, 15, 3) | |
| 26 (23, 3, 0) | |
| 26 (12, 14, 0) | |
| 19 (WWE) | |
| 18 (World) | |
| 18 (8, 10, 0) | |
| 17 (11, 6, 0) | |
| 16 (6, 10, 0) | |
| 15 (11, 4, 0) | |
| 15 (1, 5, 9) | |
| 14 (WWE) | |
| 13 (WWE) | |
| 13 (7, 6, 0) | |
| 13 (0, 7, 6) | |
| 12 (WWE) | |
| 11 (8, 0, 3) | |
| 11 (0, 5, 6) | |
| 10 (4, 6, 0) | |
| 10 (3, 7, 0) | |
| 9 (2, 1, 6) | |
| 8 (WWE) | |
| | Number | Wrestler | First event |
| 8 (3, 5, 0) | |
| 8 (3, 5, 0) | |
| 6 (WWE) | |
| 6 (WWE) | |
| 6 (3, 2, 1) | |
| 6 (5, 1, 0) | |
| 6 (1, 1, 4) | |
| 5 (3, 0, 2) | |
| 5 (ECW) | |
| 5 (3, 2, 0) | |
| 4 (WWE) | |
| 4 (WWE) | |
| 4 (2, 0, 2) | |
| 4 (World) | |
| 4 (ECW) | |
| 4 (1, 0, 3) | |
| 4 (0, 1, 3) | |
| 4 (ECW) | |
| 4 (2, 2, 0) | |
| 3 (WWE) | |
| 3 (2, 1, 0) | |
| 2 (WWE) | |
| 2 (WWE) | |
| 2 (1, 0, 1) | |
| 2 (WWE) | |
| 2 (World) | |
| 2 (1, 0, 1) | |
| 2 (0, 1, 1) | |
| 2 (ECW) | |
| 2 (0, 1, 1) | |
| 2 (1, 0, 1) | |
| 2 (WWE) | |
| | Number | Wrestler | First event |
| 2 (ECW) | |
| 2 (WWE) | |
| 2 (WWE) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (ECW) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (ECW) | |
| 1 (World) | |
| 1 (ECW) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (WWE) | |
| 1 (World) | |
| 1 (World) | |
| 1 (World) | |
| 1 (dark match) | |
| RR92 | |
| RR92 | |
| RR92 | |
| RR92 | |
| RR92 | |
| RR92 | |
| RR92 | |
| RR92 | |
| RR92 | |
| RR92 | |
| RR92 | |
| RR92 | |
| RR92 | |
| RR92 | |
| RR92 | |
| RR92 | |
| RR92 | |
| RR92 | |
| RR92 | |
|