| Unhelpful Hint | Team |
| Derived from Windsor | |
| By name, might fit in Hollywood or Broadway | |
| Been to Cup Finals thrice, lost in Cup Finals thrice | |
| Rather tame name | |
| Jagr-mister! :) | |
| Disney may ring a bell | |
| Named after animal not native to region | |
| Hey! It's a team AGAIN! | |
| THIS ITSELF IS A CLUE | |
| Not the Narrow Avenue Nerds, but... | |
| Not yellowjacket bumblebees, but... | |
| Sort of from New York | |
| One of the Staal brothers was drafted by them | |
| Usually accompanied by sound | |
| Named after animal in area. Hint: 'They're extinct' | |
| Named after animal near area | |
| | Unhelpful Hint | Team |
| The 2nd-longest streak without winning a Cup belongs to these guys | |
| Another team from New York | |
| Also, from New York | |
| Before they moved, Eric Lindros's 'favorite' team | |
| Wayne Gretzky played for this team | |
| Has had... one coach | |
| Named after subsection of population in city | |
| Only team to beat Montreal at Forum to win a Cup | |
| Named after animal in area | |
| One of the Staal brothers (as of 2011) plays for them | |
| Has won 5 Stanley Cups | |
| By name, might better suit Buffalo | |
| Two words: most cups | |
| A team from New York | |
| 1967 | |
|