| Hint | | Difficulty |
| All-time Home Run Leader | |
| All-Time Hits Leader | |
| Single-season Hits Leader | |
| Made famous catch off Vic Wertz in Giants/Indians World Series | |
| Hit Game 7 walkoff home run in 1960 World Series | |
| Got 3000th hit off of Jon Matlack, died in plane crash | |
| 4191 hits, stolen base record passed by Lou Brock | |
| Jewish Tigers first baseman, almost broke Ruth's record | |
| 1985 National League Cy Young Award Winner | |
| 1815 hits at home, 1815 hits away from home | |
| Philadelphia Phillies manager who insulted Jackie Robinson | |
| Player with most batting titles not in Hall of Fame | |
| Italian Yankees shortstop of the late 1930's, nicknamed 'Crow' | |
| | Hint | | Difficulty |
| All-time stolen base leader at third base, 'The Freshest Man on Earth' | |
| Along with Tom Glavine, Lefty Grove, Randy Johnson, Warren Spahn, and Steve Carlton, the only lefty to win 300 games | |
| Dodgers manager of the early 1950's who featured prominently in 'Boys of Summer' | |
| Giants owner who feuded with Amos Rusie | |
| Last black player before Jackie Robinson | |
| One of two finalists of the Indian Million Dollar Arm competition | |
| Player not named Bert Campaneris who played all nine positions in one game | |
| First president to throw out first pitch | |
| Player who appeared on 'The Love Boat' | |
| The player who invented the slider | |
| First player to hit 4 home runs in one game | |
| Spell a certain Red Sox left fielder's name | |
| Spell a certain Philadelphia A's left fielder's name | |
|