| Team & Year | Player | Hometown |
|---|
| New York Yankees SS (1950) | |
| Philadelphia Athletics RP (1952) | |
| Toronto Maple Leafs C (1955) | |
| Montreal Canadiens C (1956) | |
| Pittsburgh Pirates SS (1960) | |
| Philadelphia Warriors C (1960) | |
| Montreal Canadiens RW (1961) | |
| Montreal Canadiens G (1962) | |
| Montreal Canadiens C (1964) | |
| St. Louis Cardinals 3B (1964) | |
| Philadelphia 76ers C (1966) | |
| Philadelphia 76ers C (1967) | |
| Philadelphia 76ers C (1968) | |
| San Francisco 49ers QB (1970) | |
| Cincinnati Reds OF (1973) | |
| Montreal Canadiens RW (1977) | |
| Montreal Canadiens RW (1978) | |
| Houston Oilers RB (1979) | |
| Baltimore Orioles SS (1983) | |
| Los Angeles Raiders RB (1985) | |
MLB Teams
NBA Teams
Division I Basketball
