| Questions | Answers | Hints |
| Castiel replaces the church window of Jesus with a picture of who? | |
| What were God's first creature's called? | |
| At what time does Death create an eclipse? | |
| Sam has hallucinations of who? | |
| What color is Leviathan ooze? | |
| Sam has a bad cut where? | |
| What is the name of the hospital in Sioux Falls? | |
| What building is burned down? | |
| What leg does Dean break early in the season? | |
| Where is Rufus' cabin located? | |
| In The Girl Next Door Sam picks up a newspaper, what is the headline? | |
| What is Amy? | |
| What is the name of the Egyptian god that confonts people's guilt? | |
| | Questions | Answers | Hints |
| What are Don and Maggie Stark? | |
| Who is the leader of the Leviathans? | |
| What new identities does Frank give the boys? | |
| What kind of people live in Lily Dale? | |
| What were the Fox sisters first names? | |
| Who does Sam marry? | |
| Who does Dean hunt with while Sam is gone in Season Seven, Time for a Wedding? | |
| What wedding present does Dean get Sam? | |
| What is Frank's last name? | |
| What kind of sandwich is making people not care about things? | |
| What is the name of the waiter at Biggerson's? | |
| What does the waiter call Bobby? | |
| What do the guys first think they are hunting in How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters? | |
| | Questions | Answers | Hints |
| What episode does Bobby die in? | |
| Where was Bobby shot at? | |
| What are the numbers Bobby writes on Sam's hand? | |
| Lee Chamber's daughter's name is...? | |
| What do Bobby's numbers end up being? | |
| What year does Dean travel to in Time After Time? | |
| What is the name of the hunter Dean hunts with in Time After Time? | |
| At what bar does Dean meet Lydia? | |
| What creature is Lydia? | |
| What is Dean and Lydia's daughter's name? | |
| What is the name of the kid's play place that Sam is scared of? | |
| What toy does Dean try to get enough tickets for? | |
| Four years ago Sam and Dean exorcised a demon from a guy named...? | |
| | Questions | Answers | Hints |
| What ballet is the ballerina dancing to when she dances herself to death? | |
| When Sam has a mental breakdown he is locked in the psychiatric ward of what hospital? | |
| Castiel is found going by the name Emmanuel which he says was found on what website? | |
| What is the Japanese monster that can only be seen by people who are drunk? | |
| What is the name of the ghost rumored to haunt the woods in Party On, Garth? | |
| The boys first see Bobby's ghost in what episode? | |
| Charlie is obessed with what Harry Potter character? | |
| Castiel talks about how humans invented what...? | |
| The prophet revealed in this season is named? | |
| The Leviathans buy a high fructose corn syrup named? | |
| When Dean kills Dick he and Castiel are transported where? | |
|