| Question | Answer | Hint |
| What day was Dean resurrected? | |
| How long was Dean dead? | |
| Pamela is blinded when she looks at who? | |
| Where does Bobby live? | |
| What is Sam and Dean's grandfather's name? | |
| What is Sam and Dean's grandmother's name? | |
| What year did Mary make a deal with Azazel for John's life? | |
| When did Azazel want to come back? | |
| Jack Montgomery is what kind of creature? | |
| Which episode is in black and white? | |
| Lucy is actually a shapeshifter obessed with who? | |
| What animal scares Dean in a locker? | |
| What does Dean get infected with? | |
| | Question | Answer | Hint |
| What song does Jensen dance and lipsing to at the end of Yellow Fever? | |
| What is the name of the demon of Halloween? | |
| Don Harding is a witch pretending to be what? | |
| Where is the wishing well? | |
| What toy does Audrey wish would come to life? | |
| What do Sam and Dean tell Audrey is wrong with her teddy bear? | |
| Who gave Wes the magic coin? | |
| What is Anna Milton? | |
| How many possible seals are there to release Lucifer? | |
| How many seals have to be broken? | |
| What is the name of the demon that tortured Dean in hell? | |
| What has Anna lost? | |
| What is the name of the family in family remains? | |
| | Question | Answer | Hint |
| How many children did Rebecca Gibson have? | |
| What magical object does Charlie use to stay immortal? | |
| What are the names of Charlie's friends? | |
| After School Special shows us the boys at school in what year? | |
| What is the name of the school the boys temporarily attended and then returned for a case? | |
| What was the name of the bully in After School Special? | |
| Who was Sam's childhood friend in After School Special? | |
| What was the creature that disguised as strippers convinced men to kill their wives? | |
| How did Cole Griffin die? | |
| Who is revealed to be a traitor in On the Head of a Pin? | |
| What company do the guys work for in It's a Terrible Life? | |
| What is Dean's last name in It's a Terrible Life? | |
| What is Chuck's pen name? | |
| | Question | Answer | Hint |
| What is Chuck? | |
| What is Sam and Dean's half-brother's name? | |
| What kills Adam? | |
| When is Adam's birthday? | |
| What is Adam's mom's name? | |
| What is Castiel's vessel's name? | |
| Where is Castiel's vessel from? | |
| What is Castiel's vessel's daughter's name? | |
| Sam is locked up to detox from what? | |
| Where is Sam locked up at? | |
| Who is the first demon? | |
|