| Question | Answer | Hint |
| What is the name of the reaper? | |
| In what episode does John Winchester die? | |
| What does Sam use to talk to Dean when he is in a coma? | |
| Who owns Harvelle's Roadhouse? | |
| What is the Harvelle's daughter name? | |
| What is Sam afraid of? | |
| Where did Ash go to college? | |
| What does Gordon Walker specialize in hunting? | |
| Dean is the only person who is allowed to call Sam what? | |
| What cemetary is Mary buried in? | |
| What kind of monster is Angela? | |
| What does Sam break at the end of Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things? | |
| What is Andy Gallagher's twin's name? | |
| | Question | Answer | Hint |
| What is on Andy's van? | |
| Jo is kidnapped by the spirit of America's first serial killer, what is his name? | |
| Jo's father was killed on a hunt with who? | |
| What did danashulps end up meaning? | |
| What does Dean say is his astrological sign? | |
| At which bar does Robert Johnson play at? | |
| To make a crossroads deal a person has to bury a box containing graveyard dirt, black cat's bones, and...? | |
| What virus is Sam immune to? | |
| What was Sarge's neighbor's name? | |
| Where is Ava Wilson from? | |
| What word does Dean use as a code to tell Sam he is in trouble? | |
| What was the name of the ghost in Playthings? | |
| The ghost tried to kill Tyler by making her jump in...? | |
| | Question | Answer | Hint |
| What did Rose collect? | |
| Where did Tyler, Susan, and Rose live? | |
| Ron thinks that shapeshifters are...? | |
| Who has an ID that says Han Solo? | |
| Who was killed at Our Lady of the Angels? | |
| In Houses of the Holy we find out Sam believes in what? | |
| Dean tells Sam that he heard unicorn shoot what out of their butts? | |
| Who possesses Sam? | |
| What was Steve Wandell's job? | |
| What does Curtis say the aliens made him do? | |
| What two ghosts haunt Highway 41? | |
| What did Jonah Greely's wife do after he died? | |
| What creature is Madison? | |
| | Question | Answer | Hint |
| Who kills Madison? | |
| What is the movie being filmed in Hollywood Babylon? | |
| What prison do Sam and Dean purposely get sent to? | |
| Deacon served in the Marine's with who? | |
| What was the nickname of the large prisoner Dean fought with? | |
| What creature puts Dean into an alternate universe? | |
| In the alternate world what is Dean's girlfriend's name? | |
| Where was Jake Talley before he was transported for the yellow-eyed-demon's test? | |
| Where did the yellow-eye-demon transport all his special children to? | |
| Who kills Sam? | |
| How long is Dean given in his deal? | |
|