| Winner, Runner Up | 3rd Place | Team |
|---|
| Ricky Williams, Michael Bishop | |
| Jason White, Larry Fitzgerald | |
| Matt Leinart, Adrian Peterson | |
| Tim Tebow, Darren McFadden | |
| Desmond Howard, Casey Weldon | |
| Danny Wuerffel, Troy Davis | |
| Eddie George, Tommy Frazier | |
| Cam Newton, Andrew Luck | |
| Charles Woodson, Peyton Manning | |
| Carson Palmer, Brad Banks | |
| Reggie Bush (Vacated), Vince Young | |
| | Winner, Runner Up | 3rd Place | Team |
|---|
| Ty Detmer, Rocket Ismail | |
| Chris Weinke, Josh Heupel | |
| Geno Torretta, Marshall Faulk | |
| Rashaan Salaam, Ki-Jana Carter | |
| Ron Dayne, Joe Hamilton | |
| Troy Smith, Darren McFadden | |
| Mark Ingram, Toby Gerhart | |
| Eric Crouch, Rex Grossman | |
| Charlie Ward, Heath Shuler | |
| Sam Bradford, Colt McCoy | |
|
MLB Teams 
NFL Teams 
Division-I Basketball
