| Hint | Player | Hint |
| First Modern African-American NFL Player | |
| First NFL Championship Winner | |
| First NFL Championship Loser | |
| First NFL Draft Pick | |
| Winner of the First Overtime NFL Championship Game | |
| The First Black in the NHL | |
| The First African American | |
| | Hint | Player | Hint |
| First Black Player to win a Stanley Cup | |
| First Stanley Cup Winner | |
| First NHL team to win a Stanley Cup | |
| First Black Pinch Hitter | |
| First Black Pitcher to Play | |
| First Black Player to throw a Shutout | |
| First Black Player on the Phillies | |
|