| Hint | Survivor |
| ...gave up an immunity necklace? | |
| ...was voted off twice in a season? | |
| ...was thrown out of a challenge? | |
| ...played Survivor as a teenager? | |
| ...threw a challenge in season 13? | |
| ...is a winner from Pennsylvania? | |
| ...played consecutive seasons? | |
| ...had same placement on 2 seasons? | |
| ...visited the Great Barrier Reef? | |
| ...was called a “dumbass girl”? | |
| ...proposed at the reunion? | |
| ...voted for Courtney to win? | |
| ...was a tribe leader in Samoa? | |
| ...was in the Warrior Alliance? | |
| ...fell victim to a bottle twist? | |